Build Your Dream Team – Part 2: Hire

Hiring for Character, Training for Skills: Develop a Process to Assess for Character First, Then Skills

Now that your talent magnets are working and the applications are coming in, how do you evaluate and consider candidates? A golden rule of hiring is to hire for character first and skills second.

This may sound counterintuitive, but in the long run, it’s strategic. Poor character can lead to more headaches and quick turnover rates, even if they have all the skills to do the job. In short, character is typically preexisting and unchangeable, while skills can be learned and developed.

Download your checklist for Part 2 of the Build Your Dream Team Mini-Series!

A firm partner is shown shaking hands with one of the candidates, symbolizing a job offer.

The Character-First Philosophy

When hiring, it is crucial to understand that character traits such as integrity, resilience, and emotional intelligence are more difficult, or sometimes impossible, to teach than technical skills. And recognize that skills, such as legal research capabilities, analytical abilities, and familiarity with legal software platforms, are undoubtedly important but can be learned and sharpened through training and experience.

For instance, someone with strong emotional intelligence can navigate interpersonal dynamics and manage stress effectively, which can be pivotal in high-pressure environments.

Take the time to identify core character traits that align with your firm’s values and client service standards, because a person’s core characteristics define their approach to work and collaboration, qualities that are hard to instill.

Behavioral Interview Techniques

Implement structured behavioral interviews using the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, and Result). This approach helps you get answers to behavioral questions during an interview and allows candidates to provide clear and concise responses.

You want to ask scenario-based questions that reveal how candidates will handle ethical dilemmas, pressure, and client conflicts. Have your examples prepared before the interview, and consider how certain responses can sway the conversation. Knowing what you’re looking for can help keep your curiosity in check and stay on track during the interview.

Include multiple team members in the interview process to gain diverse perspectives on cultural fit. However, you want to avoid overcrowding the interview room to help the candidate feel more at ease and to ensure that those involved bring diverse knowledge and experience, offering different perspectives. Use situational judgment tests or case study exercises to evaluate problem-solving skills.

Character Assessment Strategies

Thoroughly check references by asking specific questions about integrity, teamwork, and handling difficult situations. Observe candidates during informal interactions, such as meals or office tours, to observe genuine behavior. Look for signs of community involvement, pro bono work, or other indicators of service-mindedness. Pay special attention to how candidates treat support staff and others they meet during the interview process.

While you’re capturing the positives, it’s important to note any predetermined red flag behavior that could bring toxicity to your company culture. Some things can be remedied, but having a pros-and-cons list can be beneficial when comparing final candidates.

Skills Development Framework

Remember, skills are great to have in a candidate off the bat, but they can be taught and sharpened through training and experience.

Create structured onboarding programs for similar roles that introduce new hires to your firm’s processes, systems, and standards. Establish mentorship initiatives pairing new attorneys with experienced practitioners, or new staff with senior staff members, to teach new hires the ins and outs of topics that can’t necessarily be covered in an onboarding orientation. This mentorship will foster growth and boost new hires’ confidence.

To improve your employees’ skill development, invest in continuing legal education and specialized training relevant to your practice areas. Providing development resources is crucial, but so are reviews to ensure they’re being used and that employees feel adequately supported in their growth initiatives. Perform regular skills assessments and develop or adjust personalized growth plans that align an individual’s professional goals with the firm’s goals.


Download Your Checklist

Build Your Dream Team – Part 2: Hire

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(required)